Levey gave this example: Assume you drive 15,000 miles per year, with gas at $4 per gallon. If your vehicle gets 15 miles per gallon, divide 15,000 by 15. Your vehicle uses 1,000 gallons per year. With gas at $4 a gallon, you're spending $4,000 a year on fuel. If you trade your vehicle in for one that gets 25 miles per gallon, your gas costs are $2,400 per year (15,000 divided by 25, or 600 gallons).
"This looks like a potential savings of $1,600 or $133 a month," Levey said. "But you also have to look at the transaction costs."
A newer car can sometimes mean higher insurance, higher monthly payments, more interest, and sales tax on the purchase. "In fact, if you try to make money by selling your old car outright, you may pay sales tax on the full purchase price compared to sales tax on the trade-in price," Levey said. "Another factor of true cost is depreciation. The gas guzzler may not be worth the loan payoff, so negative equity will be added to the cost of the new automobile."
If you're looking into a hybrid car, Levey recommends comparing the cost of the hybrid to the equivalent gas-powered vehicle. Hybrids can cost several thousand more. You have to consider the deferred cost of replacing the batteries. "The saving grace then might be a tax credit and the gas mileage," Levey said.