Hay Group’s research also indicates that many of the cuts organizations have made to labor costs due to the recession have already happened. The percentage of organizations using or considering significant labor cost reduction items is considerably lower than data reported 18 to 24 months ago.
Percentage of organizations using or considering the following labor cost reduction actions:
- Pay freezes: 18 percent
- Reduced retirement benefits: 17 percent
- Other reduced benefits: 15 percent
- Decreasing staffing levels: 10 percent
- Job sharing: 9 percent
- Furloughs: 7 percent
- Reduced working hours: 5 percent
- Salary cuts: 4 percent
One exception to this trend is the continued emphasis on increasing employee co-pays and scaling back on employer paid coverage. Nearly 50 percent of organizations report either actual recent increases in employee co-pays (or reduced employer paid coverage), or that they are considering doing this in the near future.
“Despite the optimism in our latest data, the contraction in the U.S. economy will not be reversed overnight, and neither will the return to the 3.5 percent to 4.5 percent base salary increases employees were used to receiving for much of the last decade,” added McMullen. “Along with modest base salary increases, we will likely see a continued emphasis on variable pay programs, both incentives and bonuses, as organizations emerge from the recession. Organizations are willing to pay for results, but only if they get those results.”
An area of concern revealed in the data is the lack of differentiation in base salary increases between top performers and average performers. Top performers are reported to receive a median 3.1 percent increase versus the 2.8 percent increase reported for the typical employee.
“Organizations have a difficult time differentiating pay increases when the pot of money gets smaller,” said McMullen. “Couple this with the ineffectiveness of many line managers in assessing employee performance and undifferentiated pay is the outcome. Managers have an opportunity to utilize their suite of ‘total’ reward programs – all of the financial and non-financial rewards that the organization provides – to reinforce the link back to individual and team performance.”